Monitor: Political Will Could End Eastern Ukraine Conflict Quickly
The outgoing deputy head of the monitoring mission to Ukraine of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe says newly compiled statistics prove that lack of political will is the only thing allowing near-daily outbreaks of violence to continue claiming lives in Russian-occupied eastern Ukraine.
Alexander Hug, whose 10-year OSCE appointment expires this month, also said the very people empowered to halt the conflict â" those who signed the Minsk agreement â" could make it happen within a matter of hours.
"Fourteen times now, both sides have agreed to recommit to the cease-fire, and every time this happens, daily cease-fire violations plummet from four digits to fewer than 10, and that's within a single day," Hug told VOA's Ukrainian service. "So, the military-technical part of this conflict can end within hours. Overnight. A nd this isn't speculation. We have evidenced it with our statistics based on observations made in the aftermath of recommitments."
Although OSCE reports typically reveal which side has instigated a given episode of violence, Hug said the data also show that assigning blame is futile.
"In black and white, our reports show where and by whom these violations take place," he said. "When we see heavy weapons in areas where they shouldn't be â" and we've seen thousands this year alone, 45 percent in [Ukrainian]-government-controlled areas and 55 percent in [Russian-backed-separatist-controlled] areas â" it's clear beyond any doubt who is responsible for the tanks, the mortars, these multiple rocket launch systems, because we see it and describe it in our reports, and yet the hardware doesn't move."
The data also show that pointing the finger in the aftermath of violence is counterproductive, and that amplifying the v oices of people most vulnerable to conflict â" civilians in proximity to the front lines â" has been the most effective way to reduce violence and facilitate a constructive dialogue.
"We have been outlining in sometimes gruesome detail the misery and suffering of civilians along the contact line, and I'm convinced â" as are many of my colleagues, if I can speak on their behalf â" that only dialogue" between people along the front lines and signatories to the Minsk agreement itself "will bring about a solution to this conflict," said Hug.
"It's for the sake of civilians that this conflict must end, specifically because it is civilians that do not believe in this conflict," he said. "We talk to them, and they tell us it's not their conflict; they don't understand why it continues, and all they want is for it to end."
Upward of 40,000 Ukrainians are estimated to cross the front lines each day, Hug said, indicating that most civilians aren't heavily invested in the idea of a territorially divided country, which is how the conflict is often framed by international media outlets.
"People on the ground don't believe in the contact line," he said. "It is a line that is a harsh reality every day when they have to cross it, but in their minds it doesn't exist. There are no firm lines of division.
"And with only very few exceptions have I ever seen any hatred developing on either si de of the contact line," he said, adding that that observation includes neighboring communities that have been shelled and shot at daily for years. "When you think of this fact, it's quite amazing."
Onus on Kremlin
David Kramer, former U.S. deputy assistant secretary of state, said even if Hug's data supporting an immediate cease-fire were sound, it wouldn't be sustainable unless the Kremlin saw that it had nothing more to gain from remaining in Ukraine.
"To be clear, the responsibility for stopping the conflict lies in Moscow," he said. "It lies with [Russian President Vladimir] Putin, who to this day refuses to recognize that there are Russian forces in eastern Ukraine."
Kramer, who is currently senior director for human rights and democracy at the McCain Institute for International Leadership, a Washington think tank, also said increased sanctions would be vital to progress.
"Russia invaded Ukraine, Ukraine didn't invade Russia," he said. "So, I do think we need to see a stronger effort from the West to apply more pressure on the Kremlin and its cronies because, absent that pressure, we're not going to see Putin move.
"Unfortunately, I don't think we'll see any movement until after both the presidential and parliamentary elections [in Ukraine]," he added.
Earlier on Thursday, Kurt Volker, the U.S. special envoy for Ukraine, told an Atlantic Council gathering the same thing.
"I think that Russia has essentially decided to wait out the Ukrainian election, see what happens," he said. "Maybe there'll be new opportunities that arise to get a more favorable position for Russia. So I think they intend to just play it out."
Volker's remarks came shortly after Putin told the Valdai Club in Sochi that he hoped a government more friendly to Russia would emerge from the Ukrainian presidential election, set for March 31.
"We need to wait until the internal political cycles are finished, and I really expect that we will be able to build at least some kind of relations and reach some kind of agreement with a new leadership of the country. We're ready for that, we want that," Putin told the gathering of Russian and Western foreign policy experts.
Putin charged that the current government in Kyiv led by President Petro Poroshenko has made its mark by "selling Russophobia and anti-Russian sentiments" to the West.
Volker said Russia appeared more determined than ever to continue backing separatists fighting the government in eastern Ukraine despite extensive efforts by the United States and Western Europe to pressure Russia over its aggression in Ukraine.
Coordinated sanctions critical
The best strategy for the West, Volker said, is to maintain pressure on Moscow through the economic sanctions, which were first imposed on Russia in 2014 over its annexation of Ukraine 9;s Crimean Peninsula.
"We will see whether President [Donald] Trump agrees with what Ambassador Volker has to say, but I agree that we need to put more pressure on Russia," said Alexander Vershbow, a former NATO deputy secretary-general and distinguished fellow at the Atlantic Council's Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security.
"The only way to bring about a solution in conformity with the Minsk agreement is if there more pressure on Russia, because clearly they're comfortable with the status quo," he added. "That being said, sanctions can be an overused weapon, so I think what's more important is to maintain solidarity with the Europeans and find a way to increase sanctions in a coordinated way together. Then the Russians will pay more attention."
Bogdan Tsioupine of VOA's Ukrainian service reported from London. Danila Galperovich of VOA's Russian service contributed reporting from Washington. Some info rmation for this report came from RFE.